Tuesday, July 29, 2014

Gattopardo economics



Thomas Palley has written an interesting and provocative working paper on "Gattopardo economics" -- his phrase for recent efforts to paper over the fundamental failings of mainstream economic theory by making superficial changes, thereby leaving the main structures intact. Such efforts seek "change that keeps things the same... Gattopardo economics makes change more difficult because it deceives people into thinking change has taken place. By masquerading as change, it crowds-out space for real change."

The name comes from the novel Il Gattopardo (The Leopard) by Giuseppe Tomasi di Lampedusa, about class conflict in Sicily in the 1860s. In the novel, the aristocracy engineers change of a sort that deflects the real threat to their power and leaves them still in charge. 

I don't know if Palley's account of the causes of the financial crisis and subsequent stagnation is definitely correct, but it rings true to me. It was the end result of broad financial de-regulation, coupled with relentless downward pressure on ordinary wages over the past few decades driven by globalization. This set the stage for a three decade credit bubble which ultimately burst. The part I'm not sure about is his claim that stagnant growth now is due to a lack of aggregate demand linked to soaring wealth inequality. Sounds plausible. Anyway, here's his closing summary. The whole paper is worth a read:


The structural Keynesian account of the economic crisis makes clear the role of mainstream economists and the neoliberal paradigm in creating the crisis. Scratch any side of the neoliberal policy box and you quickly find the ideas of mainstream economists. Corporate globalization was justified by appeal to economists’ comparative
advantage theory of free trade. The labor market flexibility agenda was justified by economists’ claims that unions and the minimum wage cause unemployment. The retreat from full employment was justified by the Friedman’s theory of the natural rate of unemployment which implied central banks should focus on low inflation as they cannot permanently affect unemployment. The attack on government and regulation was supported by Chicago School claims that costs of market failure are small relative the costs of government failure and policy induced market distortions. Government was also charged with diminishing freedom and paving “the road to serfdom”, so that freedom was best served by a minimalist government or night watchman state. Financial deregulation was justified by claims it would produce a free lunch by increasing efficiency of resource allocation.

After the financial crisis of 2008 many Keynesian economists hoped there would be profound change of theory within the economics profession. The profession stood discredited owing to its complete failure to anticipate the crisis, whereas Keynesian economists had anticipated the crisis and also showed how neoliberal economics contributed to it. However, change has been minimal.

That should not surprise anyone. Neoliberal economics supports the economic and political interests of powerful elites, and those elites have reason to defend it and block change. Even if only sub-consciously, professional economists also have a private (utility maximizing) interest in maintaining neoliberal ideas to the extent that they are intellectually invested in those ideas and their careers have been built on them.

Society is now engaged in a war of ideas, the outcome of which will greatly influence the future. That is because how we explain the crisis will influence the direction of future economic policy. Gattopardo economics is one of the mechanisms for blocking intellectual change. It works by muddying the water and appearing to offer change when in fact it keeps everything the same. That is why it is so important to expose gattopardo economics.

10 comments:

  1. I don’t know what about physics of finance but I know exactly that people have a lot of financial problems today. I see how more and more people take different loans. Today there are very popular web-site: Samedayloanspayday.com. . Here you can get any sort of financial help. Visit this site and get cash without any problems.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I will suggest for students creative business voicemail greetings that have many opportunities for students.

    ReplyDelete
  3. There are many investment advisory some of them really best who provides fantastic news. Epic Research also included in those advisory.

    ReplyDelete
  4. World Wide most accurate Forex signals service provider – Hot Forex Signal. Trial Package - $ 21.1 for 7 days. Visit for more information - Forex Trading signals

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have read your articles many times and I am always inspired by your tips and knowledge. Thank you for sharing.
    Free Trading tips

    ReplyDelete
  6. Trailer for rent in Sharjah . We are providing Transportation services with (40ft) Flatbed Trailers and Trucks throughout the UAE, 24/7 hours. We are a Trailers rental companies in Sharjah. Get comfortable trucks and trailers for cheap rental service.

    ReplyDelete
  7. We are the professional furniture packers furniture packers and movers in Dubai. Providing Cheapest Movers Service, Reliable and Hassle-free Service. We are expert and professional in packing and moving your office furniture in Dubai. Our office move action plans are carefully drawn up to minimize the loss or damages of your office furniture.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Villa Movers and Packers Dubai Our team can help you with packing, unpacking, loading, and unloading of your belongings. We are Best Movers and Packers in Dubai, Moving Companies, Villa Movers in Dubai, Local Movers in Dubai. Best Dubai movers and packers for office, house, villa shifting and storage in Dubai. As a leading packers and movers in Dubai, we are a 'one-stop-shop' for all your office relocation needs.

    ReplyDelete